The Young One said:RyanA said:The Falcons still suck even with Vick, this will be seen in the playoffs, hes the most overrated player in the NFL, he is Deion Sanders playing QB. If youre gonna make that argument, there are 10 other players that would be picked ahead of Vick, including Manning. You take Manning out of that offense and it doesnt go anywhere, half their success is their no huddle and him reading at the line before calling the play. That doesnt work very well, as we've seen, with Jim Sorgi. Take away Culpepper, the Vikings suck, take away Mcnabb, the Eagles are the Redskins (good rb, good D, and suck major ass).
i think if you reverse the injuries, and have mcnabb out instead of owens, the eagles are still the favorites to go to the bowl from the nfc. if you take out culpepper they still have nate burrelson, randy moss, michael bennet, and onterio smith, non of which are bad players. if you take vick out, whos gonna make plays. not peerless, or dunn, or alstott :roll: until this year i did think vick was the most overrated, but i reanalzyed and he does the most for his team. whens the last time peyton ran for a 20 yard gain :?:
When was the last time Vick passed for 300 yards in a game, let alone a 1st half?
I know Joe Montana has been gone for a long time, sarcasm, its my friend
Put Manning on the Falcons, they are better this year than they were with Vick. Put Vick on the Colts, they are far much worse than they are with Manning. MVP = Manning
Lets talk about Vanderjagt, or a game, or something else that was 1 biased vote away from being unanimous