Stingray
Supreme Jackass
- Joined
- Dec 5, 2003
- Messages
- 776
- Reaction score
- 543
I'm snipping out the parts I don't have/need responses for, just because I'm too lazy to keep going back and putting the quotes code.
Replies in order of the above:
I'm not denying he's done well with Atlanta. But I don't see him doing anywhere CLOSE to that with any other team.
Yeah, I should've rounded up...I read it wrong as 724 rather than 774.
That one I'll give ya. Crumpler IS a strong blocking TE. But even compared to other blocking & recieving TE's, it's an iffy race. Again, you've got the Heap's & Jolleys, one only played 6 games & put up comparitive numbers, the other played on one of the league's worst offenses this season, and halved Crumpler's numbers...(Heap's not all that great either imo....Jolley does impress me a bit though. He moves REALLY well for his size...)
hodgepodge said:Stingray said:Crumper....700 yards, 6 TDs, right? Bubba Franks, 7 TDs on the season, Antonio Gates, 900 yards, 13 TDs on the season, Tony gonzales, 1000+, 7 TDs on the season, Todd Heap--who played those whole 6 games--300+ yards, 3 TDs on the season, hell...Doug Jolley, with Oakland--who's opponents caught more passes than their recievers did--managed over 300 yards, almost 12 per carry, and 2 TDs. 700 & 6 doesn't make him a great player, it makes him a good Falcon.
I never said he was the best TE or a "great" player but he is pretty damn good. If you factor in how little passing yards the Falcons average per game (#30 in the NFL with only 168.2 yards per game) his numbers seem more impressive
(and not to nitpick or anything but you should have rounded to 800 instead of 700 since it was 774).
Something you cannot measure is how much better of a blocking TE Crumpler is than Gonzalez or Gates.
Replies in order of the above:
I'm not denying he's done well with Atlanta. But I don't see him doing anywhere CLOSE to that with any other team.
Yeah, I should've rounded up...I read it wrong as 724 rather than 774.
That one I'll give ya. Crumpler IS a strong blocking TE. But even compared to other blocking & recieving TE's, it's an iffy race. Again, you've got the Heap's & Jolleys, one only played 6 games & put up comparitive numbers, the other played on one of the league's worst offenses this season, and halved Crumpler's numbers...(Heap's not all that great either imo....Jolley does impress me a bit though. He moves REALLY well for his size...)